Avalanche Software is sending mixed signals, and the Wizarding World fanbase is on high alert. Hogwarts Legacy smashed records with over 40 million units sold, proving that single-player adventures are still a dominant force.
However, recent activity at the studio suggests a potential shift in strategy that risks dividing those loyal fans. While a sequel is all but confirmed, the exact nature of the project remains a mystery, and new clues point toward a controversial direction.
Learn more about the cancelled DLC for Hogwarts Legacy
HL2 Multiplayer Evidence
Avalanche Software has been aggressively recruiting, and the terminology used in their job descriptions is raising eyebrows. Over the past year, several listings have flagged terms like “Live Service,” “PvP,” and “Online Multiplayer RPG.”
A recent posting for a Senior Software Engineer explicitly seeks talent for a “new online multiplayer RPG.” The role involves building backend infrastructure to support connected gameplay.
This description sits in stark contrast to the immersive, solo experience that made the first game a global phenomenon. For players burnt out on microtransactions and battle passes, this pivot is concerning.
Thank you to our Community for 40 Million Units sold! #HogwartsLegacy pic.twitter.com/dax3J85vKD
— Hogwarts Legacy (@HogwartsLegacy) December 17, 2025
A Hybrid Wizarding World Sequel?
There is a silver lining. Not every job listing points to an online-only future. The studio also posted a recruitment notice for a “high-quality single-player action-adventure RPG” set specifically in the Wizarding World.
This distinction suggests Avalanche might be cooking up two separate projects simultaneously:
- A direct, single-player successor to Hogwarts Legacy.
- A standalone multiplayer experience to capture the live-service market.
Warner Bros. saw mixed results with Harry Potter: Quidditch Champions, but the demand for cooperative play in the Hogwarts universe remains high. If managed correctly, a separate online title could satisfy competitive players without diluting the narrative depth of the main sequel.
Hogwarts Legacy: The Smart Shopper Angle
If you have not yet experienced the game that sold 40 million copies, now is the perfect time to jump in. The “hype tax” is gone, and prices have stabilized.
Buying the original game now allows you to explore the 1800s Wizarding World without the launch-window premium. Plus, it serves as the perfect baseline to understand what Avalanche got right before they potentially experiment with new online mechanics.
Verdict: Is Hogwarts Legacy 2 Risking It?
The anxiety surrounding a live-service Hogwarts Legacy 2 is valid but perhaps premature. The existence of a specific “single-player” job listing offers a strong safety net for traditional RPG fans.
Avalanche Software understands their audience. The most likely scenario is a diverse portfolio offering both a narrative sequel and a separate online playground.
Are you open to a multiplayer Hogwarts experience, or should the franchise remain strictly single-player?
Download the Allkeyshop Browser Extension Free
For all the latest video game news, trailers, and best deals, make sure to bookmark us.
You can find all the best and cheapest online deals on CD keys, game codes, gift cards, and antivirus software from the verified CD key sellers on our store pages.
To not miss any news on Allkeyshop, subscribe on
Google News
.